Journal: Would You Trade Your 911 For An Electric Porsche If It Were RWD?

Would You Trade Your 911 For An Electric Porsche If It Were RWD?

Alex Sobran By Alex Sobran
March 13, 2018
7 comments

Images courtesy of Porsche

Porsche surprised plenty of people last week at the Geneva Motor Show with their Mission E Cross Turismo concept, but even more intriguing than the sleek soccer mom’s rock crawler was what was said in the roundtable interview that followed.

Stefan Weckbach, Porsche’s head of electric vehicle development, fielded a few questions about the company’s outlook regarding road-going EVs, and he hinted at the possibility of two-door and convertible models joining the Mission E range in the future: “If you talk about two-door cars or convertibles, the platform will be ready for that.”

He’s referring to the Mission E platform called J1 that’s underpinning the all-electric production sedan due to arrive on dealer floors sometime next year; it was developed in-house for Porsche alone, rather than a larger segment of VAG which will have its own shared electric platforms. Unlike Audi’s E-tron systems which rely on current-excited motors, Porsche decided to fit the Mission E with what are called permanent-magnet motors on the front and rear axle of the all-wheel drive electric sedan and Turismo models (there will be no SUVs on J1), and the advanced cooling properties of these units will allow for more consistent acceleration and top speed when the car is being driven hard for sustained periods; Porsche is promising that the Mission E will still perform admirably in any track day duties should its owners decide on a few silent hot laps from time to time.

Besides hinting at the coupe and convertibles that may be in the Mission E’s pipeline, Weckbach also mentioned that his team is “Definitely discussing rear-wheel-drive options right now.” Since ditching the front-axle power unit would result in a significant loss of regenerative braking force as well as a new weight balance challenge, it’s not as simple as just taking out the front-wheel drive motor. The all-wheel drive Mission E sedan should have a horsepower figure in the range of 600 if the Cross Turismo’s stats are any indication (an all-wheel drive model will be the most powerful Mission E car on the platform), so any rear-wheel drive Mission E variants will likely have significantly less thrust and require some novel engineering regarding the car’s effective range. 

The idea of an all-electric 911 has been floated in the past, so this could be the beginning of the path toward that hypothetical car. There’s still a wide moat between that and say the current GT2 RS, but progress is certainly being made. I’m sure to some this is the last thing they’d call progress (especially if it were to eventually replace petrol-powered 911s), but if electric is the foreseeable future of driving, shouldn’t we be making the best of it? What do you think?

Join the Conversation
Related

7
Leave a Reply

avatar
Photo and Image Files
 
 
 
6 Comment threads
1 Thread replies
4 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
7 Comment authors
Douglas AndersonPhil HuffstatlerFrankDan WilsGary Groce Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Douglas Anderson
Douglas Anderson

I’m an old guy , but still love anything Porsche. Have been blessed to own a few. I cannot get my head around all these so called electric or hybrid cars truly being drivers cars. So you have one and decide to go motoring maybe 6 or 7 hundred miles. Do you then spend half the enjoyment looking for a recharge station ?
Perhaps in the far distant future ( 15–20 years) It won’t be a problem.

Phil Huffstatler
Phil Huffstatler

No, I won’t trade my 911 for a Mission E. Technically brilliant? Yes, it sure is. A “drivers” car? Doubt it. A wealthy man’s visual statement? Absolutely. A 911? Nope, not ever.

911erFrank
911erFrank

No, I wouldn’t. It’s cerntainly a fancy car. But my 911 is about me, making me happy as a driver and car enthusiast. These Tesla-look-alikes are as appealing as a dentists treatment room.

Dan Wils
Dan Wils

Very futuristic looking car, but please it´s not a 911 it´s a Mission E with some similar shapes of a 911. Would I like to own one?.. I´m not sure..?

Gary Groce
Gary Groce

It’s great…But don’t call it a 911 please. In fact, really, for any Porsche to be referred to as a 911, it needs to have a rear mounted air cooled six cylinder motor in a rear wheel drive configuration and the same basic 2 door shape as the classic. The only thing in common here is that it’s sitting on 4 tires……sorry.

Matthew Lange
Matthew Lange

If the rumours are true then the production version of the Mission E could prove to be a very appealling package. Not sure if it would be an alternative to a 911 but would certainly look at one over a Panamera.

A two door coupe version would surely be a modern electric 928 rather than a 911 rival.

Afshin Behnia
Afshin Behnia

Agreed. Not to mention that it’s simply beautiful, inside and out. The Mission E and the Honda Urban EV Concept are two electric cars I would consider just on looks alone.